Best Organic Baby Formulas: 2023 Guide
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please read my disclosure.This in-depth, parent-friendly guide will help you find and buy the best organic baby formula. You will learn why you should consider organic formula, what ingredients to avoid in formula, and where you can reliably purchase the best organic baby formulas. This guide is updated monthly to ensure that all of the information below is recent and accurate!
Click here to see the 10 best organic baby formulas!
Table of Contents
hide
What Is Organic Baby Formula?
Organic baby formula is formula made with at least 95% organic ingredients. This means all of the ingredients in the formula have to adhere to organic standards which include:
- No GMOs (Genetically Modified Organisms)
- No growth hormones or steroids
- No antibiotics (or used extremely rarely – only when an animal is extremely sick and no other options will resolve the issue)
- No artificial colors or flavors
- All animals are fed an organic diet
- No synthetic / artificial preservatives
- No pesticides or insecticides
In Europe, these standards are more heavily regulated than in the US, and additional considerations are added like:
- No sugar or syrup solids
- Requires at least 30% of calories from lactose (the naturally occurring carbohydrate in milk)
- No synthetic nutrients extracted with chemical solvents
Note: Certified organic is different than “made with organic ingredients.” If a package has the label “made with organic ingredients” it means that 70% of the ingredients are organic, not 95%.
Is Organic Baby Formula Better For Your Baby?
The benefits to buying organic baby formula are similar to buying organic foods in general. By buying organic baby formula, you can guarantee that your baby’s formula is made without growth hormones, genetically modified ingredients, pesticides, herbicides, fungicides, antibiotics, etc.
Most organic baby formulas also have the added plus of not using ingredients like syrup solids, carrageenan, etc. that aren’t beneficial for your baby.
Many doctors will say that there isn’t enough research on the topic of whether infant organic formula provides your baby with a clear, long term health advantage (vs. conventional formula). Organic milk formula also tends to be more expensive.
That said, if you can afford organic all natural formula, those added benefits might be worth it to you, provided that the cost of organic formula brands fits your budget.
Luckily, there are some budget friendly organic formula options available (see our quick picks below). And if you can’t afford an organic formula, I recommend choosing a non organic formula that meets our criteria for choosing the best formula overall (so while you may not be able to find an organic formula that fits your budget, you may still be able to find a non-organic clean formula for babies that does not include syrup solids, carrageenan, etc. that you can afford).
Quick Picks: Best Organic Baby Formula
Here is our “at a glance” view of the best baby formula for different needs. Looking for an affordable clean baby formula? A hypoallergenic formula? The best overall? We have you covered.
We chose these formulas based on: over 100 hours of research, speaking with thousands of parents on what has worked for their children (along with personal experience with my own two kids), reviewing the ingredients of over 65 different formula brands, stages and varieties, speaking with doctors and pediatricians, and reviewing countless articles and peer reviewed studies.
Further down in this guide you will find a detailed list of the top 10 best organic baby formulas, a few runner ups (good formula brands that didn’t make our top list), and why we love each of those options.
- Best USDA And EU Certified Organic Baby Formula: Bobbie Organic Infant Formula (learn more: Bobbie Formula Review)
- Best Organic Formula Overall: HiPP Dutch
- Best Formula For Breastfed Babies: Kendamil Organic
- Best Formula For Newborns or Premies: Löwenzahn PRE
- Best Formula For Colic And Reflux: HiPP AR
- Best Budget Friendly Organic Baby Formula: Happy Baby Organic Baby Formula (Runner Up: Earth’s Best Organic Baby Formula)
- Best Hypoallergenic Baby Formula: HiPP HA
- Best Goat Milk Baby Formula: Jovie Goat Baby Formula
- Best Toddler Formula: HiPP Dutch Stage 3 or Serenity Kids (for a US option)
- Best Goat Milk Toddler Formula: Kabrita USA
Some of the items below were given to me to review by the manufacturer or as part of an affiliate program. I may receive commissions if you make a purchase through the links provided. I only recommend products I’ve actually evaluated, I believe are the highest quality, and can do the most to help you and your family. By purchasing any of these products from the links below, you help keep this blog running, so thanks for your support!
Keep in mind that every person & situation is different, especially yours, so make sure to talk to your doctor and see how these guidelines and tips can help you. These tips are not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Never disregard or delay in seeking professional medical advice because of something you read here!
What Are The Different Types Of Baby Formula?
- Organic Cow’s Milk Based Formula: Most of this type of clean infant formula found at the grocery store is made from cow’s milk, and organic milk formula assures that at least 95 percent of all the ingredients and processing aids are organic and that the product is free from preservatives, toxins, artificial colors, and artificial flavors.
- Non-Organic Cow’s Milk: Non-organic cow’s milk formula is still made from cow’s milk (hence the name), yet it might contain hormones, chemicals, and pesticides since it is not organic.
- Organic Goat’s Milk Baby Formula: Goat milk is very similar to dairy-based formulas in terms of nutrients. But, because it’s made from goat milk which contains the A2 milk protein (vs. A1 for cow’s milk), it may be easier for some babies to digest who are intolerant to cow’s milk. Organic goat’s milk is non-GMO and free from preservatives, toxins, etc. Learn more: Goat Milk Formula vs. Cow Milk Formula and Benefits Of Goat Milk Formula.
- Non-Organic Goat’s Milk: Non-organic goat’s milk is more common than its organic counterpart. However, it is a popular option because non organic goat milk still has the A2 vs. A1 milk protein.
- Partially Hydrolyzed (Hypoallergenic Formula): Hydrolyzed formulas have partially (or completely) broken down milk proteins, which may help babies with a milk protein allergy or who just have more sensitive tummies.
- A2 Milk: A2 milk is an alternative to regular cow’s milk that is often easier for babies to digest. A2 milk can come from goats, or from a small population of cow’s that happen to produce A2 vs. A1 milk.
- Soy Based: These formulas don’t contain any milk and use soy protein as the base. They are a non dairy formula option. Note: You should always consult your pediatrician before considering a soy formula for your child, due to research that shows it may not be suitable for all babies.
- Toddler Formula: While most toddlers don’t need formula, toddler formula is designed to be consumed after a child’s first year of life. Essentially, it is a kind of transition formula, and can be used to supplement a picky eater’s diet with critical nutrients.
- Plant Based Baby Formula: Plant-based formula is made without using animal products. Basically, you can think of it as being a dairy free baby formula or vegan formula option. Formulas like Else and Baby’s Only Pea Protein are common vegan formulas available in the US. See this guide for the best dairy free and vegan baby formula.
- Powder Vs. Liquid: Most all natural infant formula comes in a powdered option, where you have to mix the water before serving. Some powdered formulas will also have a liquid option, which means the formula is already pre-mixed and pre-made so you can feed it to your baby immediately. Liquid formulas are also known as “ready to feed” formulas. There are some organic ready made formula options, but they may have more stabilizers than powdered versions to keep them shelf stable.
European Vs. American Baby Formula
When I was choosing a natural infant formula for my kids, I chose a European Organic Baby Formula instead of purchasing one from the US. What’s the difference between European and US baby formula?
All US based formulas are regulated by the FDA and organic milk based formula brands earn a certification from the USDA on top of being regulated by the FDA. The FDA is responsible for ensuring formulas meet infant nutrition requirements, while the USDA Organic certification means that the baby organic formula is adhering to the organic guidelines mentioned above (e.g. no pesticides, antibiotics, etc.).
All European Formulas are regulated by the European Commission, which also certifies formulas as organic. Additionally, Europe has designations that are “beyond organic” like “Demeter” or “Bioland”.
Demeter essentially means biodynamic farming on top of organic farming. It is focused on creating the most humane conditions for the cows and ensuring the farm “gives back” to the environment in their practices. “Bioland” means that the entire farm is 100% organic and there are no nonorganic products produced on that farm. Bioland is more strict than organic, but not as strict as Demeter. Holle is the only European formula that is Demeter certified, and Lebenswert is Bioland certified.
It’s worth nothing that the EU and USDA are aligned on a few things when it comes to what gets the official “Organic” label:
- Both US and European formulas can only be considered organic if 95% or more of the ingredients are organic.
- Both US and European organic formulas will not come from cows that have been given artificial growth hormones.
- Both US and European formulas will contain the essential nutrients to support baby’s growth and development.
So Why Choose European Formulas? Overall, Europe has higher standards and has more options for high quality organic formula available to parents. There are some American Brands that are similar to European brands in quality and ingredients, and we have included those options in this guide as well.
When it comes to regulation, anecdotally I have heard and seen that Europe regulates organic standards much more strictly than the US does. Not only do European organic baby formulas have to meet the 95%+ organic ingredients, the EU requires more transparency and has stricter regulations when it comes to detecting trace amounts of any toxic substances in natural baby formula.
Historically, most formulas, especially those produced in the United States, have been loaded with ingredients that aren’t very healthy for your baby.
The good news is, there are more and more high-quality, organic baby formulas available to parents today.
How To Choose The Best Baby Formula
While all of this information might seem overwhelming, at the very least, I recommend following these guidelines when choosing the best formula for your baby:
- Organic if possible, and if you can’t afford organic, try to find a non-GMO or at least a formula with no syrup solids.
- Helpful nutrients – added DHA, ARA for brain development, prebiotics & probiotics for immune and gut health.
- Strong reviews from other parents (we used organic formula reviews as criteria for ranking the options below as well!)
- Pediatrician approval – your pediatrician knows your baby and has experience with many of these formulas, so they should be able to help you figure out which of these formulas will suit your baby the best!
This list includes both European and US formulas. Go to this guide for the best baby formula brands made in the US if you’re specifically interested in US made baby formulas!
Below, I have summarized my research to help answer the question: what is the best organic baby formula available today? Later in the post, I cover what to look for in choosing an organic baby formula, the main ingredients to avoid in baby formula, provide an analysis of each top formula, include a detailed chart that ranks all of the organic formulas available, and list a few reliable places to buy formulas online.
The 10 Best Organic Baby Formulas (Summary)
While there is no perfect natural formula, the baby formulas below are considerably better than the rest. Read on to see the best natural formula for babies and our top picks based on your baby’s individual needs.
HiPP Dutch Stage 1
The best overall organic baby formula. It has high quality formula ingredients including: a whey-to-casein ratio that mimics breast milk, uses vegetable oils for fat, contains prebiotics and probiotics, and contains DHA/ARA. It’s also free of GMO ingredients, added sugars, starch, soy, and synthetic nutrients and preservatives.
Kendamil
Kendamil also uses whole milk (instead of skimmed milk) and contains no soy or palm oil! It’s made in the UK and is the best option for parents who want a whole milk formula with DHA, ARA and prebiotics added. It also contains HMOs (human milk oligosaccharides) which are meant to help strengthen your baby’s immune system by promoting good gut bacteria. Kendamil is free of added sugars, GMO ingredients, starch and preservatives. It does contain Taurine, L-Carnitine, and Nucleotides – but Kendamil does not use solvents to extract these nutrients.
Jovie Goat
The best goat milk infant formula. Made with organic whole A2 Goat Milk and organic lactose instead of skim milk like most other formulas. Has no palm oil, no soy, no added sugars, and has DHA/ARA with NO hexane extraction. This infant formula closest to breastmilk as it contains prebiotics and has a whey:casein ratio that mimics breastmilk for easy digestion.
Löwenzahn Organics Stage PRE/1
Löwenzahn Organics is one of the newer European formulas on the market, but they are already proving to be one of the best organic formulas available today! Made in Germany, this formula mimics breastmilk, is 100% vegetarian but includes both DHA and ARA in a 1:1 ratio, includes prebiotics, and their entire production chain is completely transparent – the packaging of every product has a code that you can use to retrieve information about where the raw materials used in production are from.
Bobbie Organic Infant Formula
The only mom founded and led infant formula company in the U.S. Bobbie is the first Organic, European-Style Infant Formula that meets FDA requirements. Bobbie’s recipe is modeled after breast milk. It is the best US formula, and is also designed to meet the most recent EU nutritional standards for critical ingredients like DHA and iron, while also meeting all FDA nutritional standards for infant formula. It is an organic grass fed infant formula that tastes like breast milk. This formula without palm oil is also USDA Organic, Milk sourced from Organic Valley pasture raised cows, No Corn syrup, No Soy, No Cane sugar, No Maltodextrin, Non GMO, Gluten Free, No natural or artificial flavors or colors.
HiPP PRE Germany
This German baby formula from HiPP is a nutritionally complete formula that contains ingredients very similar to HiPP Dutch. The main difference is the packaging (comes in a cardboard box vs. a can), and HiPP PRE is designed for premature babies through 3 months of age (vs. HiPP Dutch which is meant for full term babies).
HiPP UK Stage 1
UK HiPP infant formula is also quite similar to HiPP Dutch, the main difference is that it doesn’t contain probiotics (it only has prebiotics). At $0.048/gram, it is one of the best value organic infant formula brands available.
Lebenswert Stage 1
Lebenswert provides a great option for parents who want a simple list of clean, organic ingredients. Lebenswert contains DHA, but parents will have to supplement with pre/probiotics and ARA separately. Lebenswert also has a proper whey-to-casein ratio and is free of added sugars, GMO ingredients, starch, soy, and synthetic nutrients and preservatives.
Holle PRE
Holle PRE is very comparable to Lebenswert in ingredients. It is also a great option for parents who don’t want pre/probiotics or ARA added to their formula and want to supplement with that separately (it does have DHA added). This formula is specially formulated for babies aged 0-3 months but can be used for the first 6 months of life.
Loulouka
Loulouka uses skimmed milk and contains no soy or palm oil! It’s made in Switzerland and is the best option for parents who want a formula with DHA and prebiotics added (and are ok with supplementing with ARA/probiotics separately). Loulouka is also free of added sugars, GMO ingredients, starch, and synthetic nutrients and preservatives. It’s a great option and would be higher up on our list, but it’s been out of stock for a long time and we don’t have information on when it’s coming back!
Runner Up #1: Baby’s Only with Whey
Baby’s Only Formula With Whey is also a lactose formula, but made with organic skimmed cow’s milk, and organic whey. It has no added sugars, and is free of synthetic ingredients, but lacks pre and probiotics. The DHA in Baby’s Only Nature’s One formula is derived from egg yolks, so it’s naturally extracted. Lastly, this is marketed as a toddler formula but similar to Kabrita, it meets the nutritional requirements for an infant formula. As with all formula, consult your pediatrician before using this for your baby.
Runner Up #2: Kabrita USA
The ingredients are non-GMO according to European standards, with added prebiotics and a whey-to-casein ratio that closely resembles that in breast milk. This option contains no glucose syrup solids, no maltodextrin, no taurine or l-carnitine, and uses a premium fat blend with beta palmitate. It is marketed as a toddler formula, but meets the FDA nutritional requirements for infant formula. As with all formula, consult your pediatrician before using this for your baby.
Runner Up #3: Happy Baby Organic Formula
Happy Baby Organic Formula doesn’t have gluten or corn syrup. It’s Non-GMO, and is designed for easy digestion. It contains pre and probiotics. It contains palm oil and soy oil, but has naturally derived DHA. It’s also a bit thin, so takes baby some time to get used to.
Runner Up #4: Holle Bio Stage 1
Holle is comparable to Lebenswert in ingredients, and is also a great option for parents who don’t want pre/probiotics or ARA added to their formula and want to supplement with that separately (Holle does have DHA added). The main drawback to Holle Bio is that it has maltodextrin added.
Runner Up #5: Holle Goat
A good alternative to Kabrita if you are looking for a truly organic goat milk formula with no ARA and pre/probiotics added (it does have DHA added). Like Holle Bio, the main drawback to this formula is the added maltodextrin.
Currently Out Of Stock: Loulouka Goat
Loulouka goat formula is made from organic whole goat milk from the Swiss Alps. It is 100% vegetarian and uses plant based DHA (it does not contain ARA). It has no maltodextrin, sugar or syrup solids, and Loulouka works with farms known for strict quality regulations that focus on animal welfare, sustainability and harmony with nature. It doesn’t have prebiotics or probiotics so you would have to supplement. It’s a great option and would be higher up on our list, but it’s been out of stock for a long time and we don’t have information on when it’s coming back!
Ideal Organic Baby Formula Ingredients
Here’s our ideal list of baby formula ingredients and criteria, and how we made our picks for the best formula for babies in this guide.
✅ Certified Organic (either USDA certified organic, or EU certified organic).
✅ Meets nutritional standards for babies (in the US or the EU) and includes key vitamins and minerals for development
✅ No sugar, sucrose, or syrup solids (you want a formula without sugar, where lactose is the main carbohydrate)
✅ Whey to casein ratio that matches mature breastmilk (60:40 whey to casein ratio)
✅ Includes Omega 3 Fats (DHA, ALA) and Omega 6 fatty acids (ARA, LA)
✅ Includes prebiotics and probiotics
✅ Gluten free, soy free (with the exception of organic soybean oil, and organic soy lecithin, which is ok)
✅ Palm oil free (or uses palmitic acid, or sustainable palm oil. Learn more: Palm Oil In Baby Formula)
✅ No carrageenan
✅ No hexane extracted ingredients if possible (DHA specifically), or no hexane detected post extraction
✅ No maltodextrin
✅ Mixes easily, reviews state that most babies can tolerate it well
✅ Suits your budget
Ingredients To Avoid in Organic Baby Formula
The US has a much larger range of standards for organic baby formula, which means that even the best organic formulas can have lower quality ingredients. Below are the ingredients that shouldn’t appear in organic formula – as outlined by the National Organic Standards Board – and are banned in the European Union, which really is the gold standard for what’s considered organic. Organic formula should not have:
❌ Processed Refined Sugars (Syrup, Syrup Solids): Corn syrup solids (glucose syrup solids), maltodextrin (a partially hydrolyzed starch derived from corn, rice, or potatoes), sugar, or brown rice syrup. Manufacturers use these because they are cheaper than lactose (which is what should be in formula).
❌ Oils extracted using hexane (DHA, ARA): DHA and ARA are important to have in baby formula, because they are essential fatty acids that are important for both brain development and eye development. However, specific types of DHA and ARA – C. Cohnii oil (DHA) and M. Alpina oil (ARA) are processed using hexane (a neurotoxic petroleum-based solvent). There are other forms of DHA and ARA that can be added to formula that do not require hexane for extraction. While the hexane is removed from the formula after processing and is non-detectable in European Formulas (see my detailed section on hexane at the end of this post), it’s worth noting that DHA and ARA do not need hexane for extraction when derived from sources other than algae and fungus. It’s also worth noting that any oils that are listed as “organic” on EU formula labels cannot use hexane for extraction.
❌ Carrageenan: typically added as a stabilizer to ready-to-feed formula in the US; it is not allowed in the EU and has been linked to intestinal inflammation.
❌ Synthetic Nutrients Extracted Using Chemical Solvents: This includes lutein, lycopene, nucleotides, taurine, l-carnitine and l-methionine. Some of these nutrients are not allowed in EU formulas, some of them (like lutein) are beneficial to babies, but they ideally are extracted not using hexane.
❌ Palm Oil: to mirror the levels of palmitic acid, which is found in breastmilk, some manufacturers add palm oil. The problem is that palm oil in formula does not act the same way that palmitic acid does in the baby’s gut. Palm oil reacts with calcium, and causes the formation of “soaps” in the baby’s intestines (which can cause digestive issues). Palm oil is in most formulas (EU & US), but more manufacturers are now making formula without it.
❌ Soy: Soy protein (and soy formula) are problematic for infants because of their phytoestrogen content (check out this study about soy).
Unfortunately, nearly all baby formulas sold in the US have one or more of these ingredients to avoid.
So what’s a parent to do?
Stick to the high-quality European formulas, or US formulas like Bobbie which mimic European standards.. The EU has some of the best organic baby formula options, and HiPP, Holle, and Lebenswert, all produce the high quality formulas with the best ingredients.
Below, you can find more details on the 10 best baby formulas available on the market today, and a list of places where you can buy these formulas online.
The 10 Best Organic Baby Formulas (Details)
1. HiPP Dutch – Best Overall
Why I love it: Of all the formulas, this is the best organic baby formula. It has a whey-to-casein ratio that mimics breast milk, uses vegetable oils for fat, contains prebiotics and probiotics, and contains DHA/ARA. It’s also free of GMO ingredients, added sugars, starch, soy, and synthetic nutrients and preservatives. It also comes in an easy-to-dispense, airtight container! Because of its closeness to breastmilk, it can be one of the best formulas to supplement breastfeeding. HiPP has lots of different formulas, but HiPP Dutch is the best HiPP formula you can find.
Keep in mind: If you are concerned about hexane extraction, HiPP organic baby formula uses this method to retrieve the DHA and ARA in their formula. They claim, however, that 100% of the hexane is removed after extraction and is not detectable in their formulas. Given that this European brand follows guidelines that are much more stringent than those in the US, I’m inclined to believe them.
2. Kendamil – Best Whole Milk Formula with Prebiotics, DHA and ARA
Why I love it: Kendamil is the only formula that uses whole milk instead of skimmed milk, and also does not contain soy oil or palm oil. Kendamil’s cows graze on pasture and are grass fed, they use coconut oil as one of their main fatty acids, and their formula contains non-hexane extracted DHA, ARA and Prebiotics. It is also one of the best formula milk for infants, due to its addition of HMOs and whole milk formulation. When it comes to Kendamil vs. Loulouka formula, we have ranked Kendamil first because it’s more comprehensive and is easier to find than Loulouka.
Keep in mind: This formula does not contain probiotics, so you may have to supplement if you choose this for your baby. It also contains taurine, l-carnitine, and nucleotides, but Kendamil does not use solvents to extract these nutrients for their formula.
3. Jovie Organic Goat – Best Goat Milk Formula for Babies and Toddlers
Why I love it: If you’re looking for the best organic goat milk formula, and a great alternative to cow’s milk, I’d recommend Jovie Goat. The ingredients are 100% organic, non-GMO, with added prebiotics and a whey-to-casein ratio that closely resembles that in breast milk. This best infant formula option contains no glucose syrup solids, no maltodextrin, no palm oil and no soy oil. For more details on why that’s my ideal choice for a goat milk formula, see my post on the best goat milk formulas here!
Keep in mind: Jovie doesn’t contain probiotics, so you would have to supplement. It’s also not vegetarian, as it contains fish oil.
4. Löwenzahn Organics – Best Vegetarian Friendly Formula with Prebiotics, DHA and ARA
Why I love it: Löwenzahn is the only formula that makes their entire supply chain transparent to the consumer – so you can see where all of the ingredients are sourced from by scanning a bar code on the package! They also use grass-fed, organic milk, their DHA and ARA comes from algae and does not have any detectable hexane – making it a vegetarian friendly formula! It is one of the best formulas for infants thanks to its gentle formulation, and it will grow with your baby – it comes in 3 stages from birth to 12 months.
Keep in mind: This formula does not contain probiotics, so you may have to supplement if you choose this for your baby.
5. HiPP Germany – Best for Babies 0-3 Months
Why I love it: HiPP Germany is one of the best organic brands from Europe, and is a nutritionally complete formula that contains ingredients very similar to HiPP Dutch.
Keep in mind: HiPP PRE is meant for babies 0-3 months. Also, its container is harder to dispense from than HiPP Dutch’s is (foil bags vs. an airtight can).
6. HiPP UK – Best Value
Why I love it: HiPP UK is also quite similar to HiPP Dutch. At $0.048/gram, it is the best value, healthiest organic infant formula option.
Keep in mind: The main difference between HiPP UK and HiPP Dutch (besides the price) is that it contains no probiotics, only prebiotics. Like HiPP Germany, it also has a container that’s harder to dispense from (foil bags vs. an airtight can).
7. Bobbie Organic Infant Formula – Best Organic Baby Formula Made in the US
Why I love it: Bobbie is the best organic infant formula made in the US. It is the best option if you’re looking for a US-made formula that is comparable to European formulas. It’s made by parents for parents, who are looking for a nutritious, organic, clean baby formula for their little ones. This best American formula includes DHA and ARA – and does not use hexane to extract the DHA. They do use hexane to extract the ARA, but it is not detectable in their formula. Bobbie has a 60:40 whey-casein ratio, is comparable to breastmilk, is non-GMO, free of added sugars, and has no synthetic nutrients or preservatives. It also happens to be palm oil and soy oil free! And with their starter bundle, you can try Bobbie in a budget friendly way (2 cans for only $20 per can + free shipping!)
Keep in mind: Bobbie does not add prebiotics or probiotics to their formula. Personally, I prefer pre/probiotics added to formula mainly for convenience. If you want to supplement with prebiotics, I recommend BeginHealth prebiotics. For the best probiotics for infants, see my recommendations here!
8. Lebenswert – Best Formula Without Prebiotics, Probiotics, and ARA
Why I love it: Lebenswert provides a great option for parents who want a simple list of clean, organic ingredients and who want to supplement with pre/probiotics and ARA separately. If hexane-extracted DHA and ARA concern you, Lebenswert may be just the thing you’re looking for. Lebenswert has DHA added from a non-hexane extracted source (organic fish oil). Lebenswert also has a proper whey-to-casein ratio and is free of added sugars, GMO ingredients, starch, soy, and synthetic nutrients and preservatives.
In addition to a top-notch ingredients list, this organic grass fed formula also boasts a Bioland certification, which is even more thorough than EU organic certification.
Keep in mind: Personally, I prefer pre/probiotics and DHA/ARA added to formula – mainly for convenience. If you want to supplement with prebiotics, I recommend BeginHealth prebiotics. For the best probiotics for infants, see my recommendations here!
9. Holle PRE – Comparable to Lebenswert, Formulated for Babies 0-3 Months
Why I love it: Holle PRE is very comparable to Lebenswert in ingredients, and is also a great option for parents who don’t want pre/probiotics or ARA added to their formula and want to supplement with that separately.
Holle baby formulas are Demeter biodynamic certified, which has even more stringent and careful regulations than Bioland. This ensures the purest, non-GMO ingredients, the highest standards for animal welfare, and a commitment to biodiversity and sustainability.
Keep in mind: Again, with Holle options, parents would need to supplement probiotics and ARA since it is not included in the formula (DHA is added in the new formulation). Holle PRE can be used until 6 months of age, but it’s specially formulated for babies 0-3 months. After 6 months you’ll have to move to a Stage 1 or 2 formula. As another note, Holle Bio PRE contains no added maltodextrin, but stages 1 and 2, which are still lactose-based, do contain added organic maltodextrin.
10. Loulouka – Best Formula with DHA and No Palm or Soy Oil
Why I love it: Loulouka is one of the few formulas that has DHA and prebiotics, but doesn’t contain soy oil or palm oil (it uses coconut oil instead!) Full of healthy fats, organic, from grass fed cows – it’s one of the best organic milk options for your little one, especially if you are looking for a formula free of ARA and probiotics.
Keep in mind: Like Lebenswert (which appears just a few spots down), this grass fed baby formula has no ARA or probiotics, so you will have to supplement if you choose this for your baby.
Runner Up #1: Baby’s Only with Whey – Best Toddler Formula
Why I love it: Baby’s Only with Whey is the one of the best cow’s milk-based formulas available in the US. It is made with organic skimmed cow’s milk, and organic whey. It has no added sugars, and is free of synthetic ingredients, and has naturally extracted DHA (from eggs).
Keep in mind: This is technically a toddler formula but similar to Kabrita, it meets the nutritional requirements for an infant formula. It also has no pre/probiotics so you would have to supplement with that separately. As with all formula, be sure to consult your pediatrician before using this for your baby.
Runner Up #2: Kabrita USA – Best Goat Formula Available in the US
Why I love it: There are a lot of benefits to Kabrita USA. It is FDA registered, has a super clean ingredients list, is certified glyphosate free, it contains no added sugars, no maltodextrin, no syrup solids and has the right composition of fatty acids to be gentle for babies’ tummies to digest.
Keep in mind: Kabrita is technically not organic, but it does follow European standards and is non-GMO. It’s also technically a toddler formula, but it does meet the nutritional requirements of infant formula (so just make sure your pediatrician is comfortable with you using it).
Runner Up #3: Happy Baby Organic Formula – Best Infant Formula Available in the US
Why I love it: This is one of the best infant formulas made in the US, and doesn’t have gluten or corn syrup. It’s Non-GMO, and is designed for easy digestion. It contains DHA, pre and probiotics. And it’s also the best organic infant formula available in the US (since Baby’s Only is technically a toddler formula).
Keep in mind: This American made baby formula does contain soy oil, which is less ideal. It also has a thinner consistency that not all babies might like.
Runner Up #4: Holle Bio – Best Organic Standards
Why I love it: Holle organic baby formula is very comparable to Lebenswert in ingredients, and is also a great option for parents who don’t want pre/probiotics or ARA added to their natural organic formula and want to supplement with that separately.
Holle baby formulas are Demeter biodynamic certified, which has even more stringent and careful regulations than Bioland. This organic cow milk formula has the purest, non-GMO ingredients, the highest standards for animal welfare, and a commitment to biodiversity and sustainability.
Keep in mind: Again, with Holle options, parents would need to supplement pre/probiotics and ARA since it is not included in the formula (DHA is included in this non toxic formula). Holle Stage 1 also has maltodextrin added.
Runner Up #5: Holle Goat – Budget Friendly Organic Goat Milk Formula for Infants
Why I love it: Holle Goat is the only goat milk formulas that is organic. Holle’s goat formula is also suitable for infants. Some evidence suggests the protein ratios in goat milk more closely resemble that of breast milk. There is also research that suggests goat’s milk is more easily and completely digestible by infants than cow’s milk is. This means that goat’s milk formula may be perfect for a baby with sensitivities to cow’s milk formula.
Keep in mind: Unlike Kabrita, Holle goat milk formula does not contain added whey (so the whey:casein ratio in Holle might be constipating for some babies). This organic infant milk also includes maltodextrin to balance the sweetness of the milk. It also contains no added pre/probiotics or ARA (DHA is included in the new formulation).
The Best Hypoallergenic Formulas For Babies
If you’re looking for detailed information about the best hypoallergenic baby formulas, our guide outlines the best options as well as what ingredients to look for to find the best fit for your baby. I have included a short summary of the top 3 hypoallergenic formulas below as well!
1. HiPP Hypoallergenic – Best for Cow’s Milk Protein Sensitivities or Allergies
Why I love it: HiPP Hypoallergenic baby formula is free of casein and contains protein hydrolysates that break down proteins for infants who have sensitive stomachs. It also contains pre and probiotics and DHA. Try this gentle formula without corn syrup if your baby has a cow’s milk allergy or sensitivity and you haven’t tried another hypoallergenic option (or you’re trying to move away from the US hypoallergenic options because of concerns over ingredients). Has extensively hydrolyzed protein, (86-87% broken down), 100% whey (no casein), but with the same lactose content as a non-hypoallergenic baby formula. So if your baby has severe lactose intolerance, this may not work well for them.
Keep in mind: HiPP Hypoallergenic is not technically organic, because hydrolyzing the milk protein requires more processing. However, all other ingredients included are still organic.
2. HiPP Comfort – Best for more severe cow’s milk protein allergies
Why I love it: This is the most gentle formula from the EU, and is worth trying for babies who don’t do well on HiPP HA. It is the most similar to a US hypoallergenic formula and is more broken down than HiPP HA. It contains extensively hydrolyzed protein, (86-87% broken down), 100% whey (no casein), reduced lactose content and modified fats. While technically, HiPP HA is a hypoallergenic formula and Comfort is not specifically a hypoallergenic formulation but rather indicated for gassiness, colic and constipation, we have found parents seeking a “hypoallergenic” formula have been successful with Comfort. But, their success may be due to the reduced lactose content in addition to the hydrolyzed protein.
Keep in mind: HiPP Comfort is not technically organic, because hydrolyzing the milk protein requires more processing. However, all other ingredients included are still organic. Also, while HiPP Comfort is the closest to a US hypoallergenic formula, it’s still not as broken down as Alimentum or Nutramigen (which is 93% hydrolyzed). The US hypoallergenic formulas are usually suited for babies who have a medical condition s called CMPA (cow’s milk protein allergy). So if your baby can’t tolerate Comfort you will have to move to a US hypoallergenic formula.
3. HiPP Anti-Reflux – Best for Reflux
Why I love it: HiPP Anti-Reflux formula is EU certified organic, and it is a good choice for babies with sensitive tummies. This formula uses 100% whey (and no casein) to prevent reflux or spit up. It can be one of the best formulas for gas due to its lack of casein. It contains DHA, and also contains prebiotics and probiotics to benefit your baby’s digestive system.
Keep in mind: HiPP Anti-Reflux contains organic maltodextrin (in addition to lactose). This is to help in easing digestion for little ones.
Best Organic Baby Formulas Comparison Chart
Below is a detailed chart ranking all of the best organic baby formulas, based on each of the ingredients in baby formula. You can see the differences between Kendamil vs. Hipp vs. Holle vs. Bobbie along with all of the other best baby formula brands. At the top of the chart, I’ve included a hypothetical line for the “ideal” cleanest formula. Use this line as a way to measure all of the other formulas against, to find the right baby formula for your child.
For anyone looking for a goat milk formula specifically, I have a separate organic formula comparison chart in What’s the Best Goat Milk Formula for Your Baby?
Note: Regarding GrassFed and PureBliss – while they are popular formula brands, they are not part of my best organic baby formulas list (since they are not technically organic). But they are non GMO and antibiotic free, and their ingredients list is relatively clean, so I would say they are better than all of the non-organic formulas available in the US today.
Discontinued Baby Formulas
There are a few baby formula brands I had to remove from the chart above, due to them being discontinued. They are:
- The Honest Company Organic Formula: Founded by Jessica Alba, The Honest Company was created to develop high quality baby products with clean ingredients and budget friendly prices. They had two stages of Honest organic formula, but have since discontinued both.
- Plum Organics Infant Formula: We don’t know why Plum Organics discontinued their infant formula, but it no longer appears in our guide since it’s no longer available.
- Happy Tot Toddler Formula: Has been discontinued as of a few years ago.
- Gerber Organic Formula: Also has been discontinued
Note: Due to formula shortages, Loulouka has been difficult to find, but it has not been discontinued, it’s just perpetually out of stock right now! We will update this post as soon as we hear more about Loulouka’s availability. Additionally, Similac Organic Baby Formula also seems to be out of stock, likely due to the formula shortage. It’s not one of our top picks, but it is worth mentioning since it can be a more budget friendly option.
A Note On Breastfeeding Vs. Formula Feeding
We’ve all heard the advice: “Breast is best.” For a few moms, that advice is easy to follow. Unfortunately for many moms, it’s not.
The truth is, breastfeeding is HARD.
Not hard as in “oh this is hard, I don’t feel like doing it,” but hard as in: My baby won’t latch; I have low milk supply; My nipples are sore/bleeding/blistered; I have no place to pump at work; I have mastitis; I’ve seen dozens of lactation consultants, and I’m still having problems.
And then there are all of the moms who can’t breastfeed because of a medical reason, or because they are adoptive parents (or had their children via a surrogate).
That’s all to say – if you love breastfeeding, great. But if you need to supplement or switch to formula, that’s okay!
Many moms feel guilt over weaning early or not being able to breastfeed as much as they’d like. But honestly, the most important thing is the love you give to your baby, and that you and your baby are happy and healthy. Breast isn’t best; FED is best.
For me, nursing my daughter was one of the most physically and emotionally challenging parts of new motherhood. Many of the early days ended in tears. When I weaned her after 8 months of emotionally taxing nursing and pumping, I needed to select a baby formula. Using my background in nutrition, along with extensive research (both reading articles and speaking with doctors and fellow mothers), I was able to arrive at this list of the best formula for baby in this guide.
The Best Vitamin D, DHA, And Probiotics Supplements For Babies
Recommendations on Supplementing: DHA, Vitamin D, Probiotics For Infants and Babies
I have gotten a lot of questions about what to supplement with if your baby is on a formula that doesn’t have DHA added, what probiotic to use, or what to do if your baby is getting some breastmilk along with their formula (in which case you need to add Vitamin D). Note: The EU just released new standards for DHA in baby formula and all of the EU formulas are now adhering to those standards.
If you are looking for additional supplementation for DHA, Vitamin D and/or Probiotics, here are our top picks for baby supplements:
Best Vitamin D Supplement For Babies
Raise Them Well is our top pick for Vitamin D Drops For Babies. Another good option are these Baby Vitamin D Drops. There is literally nothing added to them (no flavors, colors, etc.). They are liquid and you only need one drop in your baby’s bottle per day. You can also just apply the drop on your baby’s pacifier, on your nipple (if you’re nursing), or on your finger and have your baby suck it off. Super easy, tasteless and pure.
Best DHA Supplement For Babies
The only Omega 3 supplement I’d recommend for kids is Nordic Naturals. They have an infant DHA supplement and a children’s DHA supplement – both of which are extremely pure, have no added preservatives or sugar, and are in liquid form so they can be added to just about anything!
Best Probiotics For Babies
Garden of Life’s line of probiotics is one of our favorites. They are shipped cold and their infant/kids one can be added to your baby’s bottle (starting at 3 months of age), and can be used even when your child gets older (just add the powder to their milk).
We also like Klaire Labs’ powdered probiotic. For infants 0-3 months of age, I recommend BioGaia’s probiotic. For older kids, Garden of Life also has a kids’ chewable probiotic if you need and option that doesn’t require refrigeration, and I take their adult capsule daily. For older kids, see this guide for the best probiotics for kids.
Best Prebiotics For Babies
There is only one prebiotic I’ve found that’s safe for babies and toddlers and has super high quality ingredients and no stabilizers or artificial flavors/colors added. I recommend BeginHealth if you are looking to supplement with a prebiotic for your child.
How To Choose The Best Baby Food
For those of you transitioning to solids and looking for homemade baby food recipes, I have a bunch of easy recipes you can try here! But in those instances when you’re on the go and looking for a healthy, organic, pre-made option, my list of the healthiest baby food pouches should help.
Where Can You Buy The Best European Baby Formula In The US?
If you want to buy HiPP, Lebenswert, or Holle online, I have found a few online retailers who are either based in the US or ship to the US in a reliable and safe manner! I’m in personal contact with the owners of all of these companies, I feel comfortable recommending all of them to you.
1. The Milky Box
The Milky Box is the only online retailer I’ve found that literally has every European formula you can think of. They are dedicated to ensuring that organic European formulas are available to any parents who want them in the US! And their supply chain is so robust they virtually guarantee that they are always in stock of HiPP Dutch, HiPP UK, HiPP Germany, Holle, Lebenswert, Goat milk formula, and the sensitive formulas (HiPP HA, Comfort, Anti-Reflux).
And, they even carry more specialty formulas like Jovie Goat Milk, HiPP Goat Milk, Stage 3 and Stage 4 formula from HiPP, Holle, Jovie, Kendamil, Lebenswert, Kabrita, Nannycare, Premibio, and organic vegan baby formulas like Bebe M!
What Makes The Milky Box Stand Out?
- Guaranteed availability of ALL the European formulas
- They offer one of the largest varieties that is also the most expansive. They carry stages up until 2 years old, so that moms have the option to continue offering high quality milk to their toddlers.
- They have multiple warehouses across the world, including in Europe and North America, to ensure formula gets to you ASAP.
- A reputable supplier of Kendamil (one of two suppliers) & the only supplier of Jovie Formulas
- Free standard shipping on all 6, 8, & 12 pack orders!
- A comprehensive mixing guide for every formula listed on their website in case customers lose their instructions.
- A subscribe & save option (up to 5%) with delivery every 1-2 months. And, you can buy bundles to save more!
- Amazing customer support (turnaround within 24 hours)
- Receive an additional 10% off using the code “PICKY10” at checkout!
You can read more about The Milky Box’s story here!
2. Organic’s Best
Organic’s Best is based in Germany, and is passionate about making organic baby formula and baby food available internationally (to any family who wants it!) They carry the top organic formula options like HiPP Dutch, HiPP Germany, HiPP UK, Holle, Lebenswert, and Loulouka. They also carry HiPP HA, HiPP Comfort, and HiPP AR.
One thing that makes this company unique is that they ship internationally for free, and they will guarantee express delivery between 1-4 business days to the US. Additionally, every new customer also receives two free boxes of formula! They have low prices, and they include free shipping insurance for every order, and they guarantee availability of all formulas – so you never have to worry about your favorites being out of stock!
3. Organic Formula Shop
Organic Formula Shop is a solid company that offers a reliable and convenient shopping solution for HiPP, Holle, and Lebenswert anywhere in the United States. Based in the Netherlands, their mission is to share their gathered knowledge about European Formulas with parents and caretakers globally via their website and excellent 24/7 customer support. They also recently launched a new online store for the Indian market.
They carry some of the best clean baby formula brands like HiPP Dutch, HiPP German, Holle and Holle Goat’s milk formulas. They also carry the sensitive formulas HiPP HA & HiPP Comfort.
Some things that make this company unique include: no matter your order size, all orders are delivered for free via Express Shipping within 3 to 5 business days. If the formula you order doesn’t work for your baby, Organic Formula Shop will work with you to find the right option immediately. They are one of the lowest-priced resellers out there and allow bulk purchasing with a 20% discount. Lastly, they even offer a Single Parent Scholarship designed to support a single mother or father with their college or graduate education! I would highly recommend them as a reputable place to order your HiPP and Holle formulas.
4. Bottles & Burps
When it comes to affordability, Bottles & Burps is the lowest priced US retailer I have found that sells some of the best organic formulas for babies like HiPP, Holle, Lebenswert and Kendamil. They can get all of these products to most US households in 5 days from their warehouses.
If you’re looking to save even more, you can order bundles direct from their warehouse in Germany (with free, express 2-5 day shipping to the US). Express shipping from Europe is important because the alternatives can take upwards of 30 days and suffer additional customs delays.
I met with Courtney and Blake, the co-owners, and learned that they had the same experience as I did when trying to find healthy formula for their little one. They are committed to bringing high quality, European formula to parents in the US at an attractive price. Bottles & Burps is also offering a $10 discount code using the code PICKYEATER10 (just enter it manually in the checkout process!)
5. Organic Baby Food
Organic Baby Food is a reputable, online retailer based in the EU who has fast shipping to the US! They have the best organic formula brands like HiPP, Lebenswert, and Holle, along with Hypoallergenic formula and Goat’s Milk formula. They have reasonable prices, reliable shipping (within 1-3 business days!), amazing customer support, and I have been in contact with the owner personally.
In addition to baby formula they also have a variety of organic cereals and snacks for babies from HiPP/Holle/Leb, as well as a line of baby care products (shampoo, lotion, calendula) that are gentle and free of any synthetic ingredients so they are perfect for babies!
A few other great things about this company: guaranteed delivery within 2 days, money back if your shipment is delayed, dedicated customer support (a few hours turnaround time for emails or direct phone support at 1-800-701-4303), and deep discounts up to 60% off sometimes! They are also giving readers of The Picky Eater a 10% off coupon code at checkout – just use the code: PICKY and you will get the discount!
Baby Formula FAQs
What formula is closest to breastmilk?
Any formula that has a 60:40 whey to casein ratio, and contains the key vitamins and minerals necessary for infant development are very close to breastmilk. HiPP Dutch, Bobbie Formula, Kendamil Formula, Holle, and Lebenswert are all close to breastmilk.
Some US brands like Enfamil claim that they have the formula closest to breastmilk because they include proteins found in colostrum, like lactoferrin, however, Enfamil is not organic so I wouldn’t choose that brand over the others listed above just for the lactoferrin.
What’s the healthiest baby formula?
There are many options in this guide for the healthiest baby formula! We would rank HiPP, Kendamil, Bobbie, Holle, and Lebenswert all at the top of the list of the cleanest baby formula options.
Is organic formula really better?
Organic formulas tend to be better compared to conventional formulas because they are free from pesticides, antibiotics, chemical fertilizers, hormones, and more.
However, not all families may be able to choose organic formula. Other considerations such as price, or needing a hypoallergenic formula (which by definition will not be organic due to the hydrolyzed proteins), or availability should also be kept in mind when choosing a formula.
What’s the difference between Stage 1, Stage 2, and Stage 3 baby formula?
The different stages of formula correspond to different ages of your baby. Each stage is formulated to meet the nutritional requirements of a specific age and stage of your baby’s development.
Stage PRE/1: This stage is suitable to give to your baby from birth. These formulas tend to be lactose based, and are very gentle and easy to digest. They will contain less iron than later stages, since your baby’s iron stores remain intact until about 6 months of age. Stage PRE/1 is for babies 0-6 months old. Stage PRE is typically a formula for newborns through 3 months of age, but can be used up to 6 months. PRE is also slightly less filling than Stage 1, so you can adjust based on your baby’s appetite between these two stages during the first 6 months of life.
Stage 2: For formulas that only have 2 stages, stage 2 is for 6-12 months of life. For formulas that have 3 stages, stage 2 will typically be for 6-10 months of life. Stage 2 has more iron, and a slightly different mix of vitamins and minerals to adjust to your baby’s growing needs.
Stage 3: Typically used for 10-12 months of life, and sometimes can be used into toddlerhood. It is made specifically to supplement your baby’s diet of solid foods which should be increasing into 11-12 months of life.
All ages formula: Some formulas don’t come in stages (like Bobbie), which means that their all ages formula can be used for 0-12 months of life.
How long is baby formula good for?
According to the CDC, most baby formulas need to be used within 1 month of opening the container. Unopened formula can be good for up to 6-12 months (use the expiration date on the container to determine how long your formula is good for).
Can you mix formulas?
Yes! You absolutely can if you follow standard mixing instructions. You might want to mix formulas if you either feel like your baby does well with a mix of two formulas, or if you are trying to slowly transition from one formula to another.
Final Thoughts
Not every baby likes every formula. Some formulas constipate or irritate some babies, yet keep other babies’ tummies perfectly happy. If you try the formulas I recommend and they don’t work for your baby – that is ok!
There is no perfect formula, but some are still much better than others. If you can afford it, the best organic baby formulas are HiPP, Lebenswert, and Holle – so I’d recommend shipping your formula from Europe whenever possible! Organic infant formulas are more expensive than regular formula, and not every parent has the financial means to buy organic formula for their little ones – and that’s ok, too! Just do the best you can for your baby. No judgments here.
Overall, I advocate a world of no judgments when it comes to breastfeeding or formula feeding. All you can do as a mom is your best. Whether you breastfeed for a year, or 6 months or 1 month, or 0 months doesn’t make you a better or worse mother. A happy healthy mom and happy healthy baby is all that matters.
I hope this post helped you find the right baby formula for you and your little one!
Keep in mind that every person & situation is different, especially yours, so make sure to talk to your doctor and see how these guidelines and tips can help you. These tips are not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Never disregard or delay in seeking professional medical advice because of something you read here!
My recommendations are based on the manufacturer’s claims and ingredients list, and what I feel best giving to my own family. Your individual results may be different based on your overall diet, exercise, age, weight, family history, or pre-existing conditions.
Appendix: More Info on Hexane Extracted DHA/ARA in Formula
I spoke with an expert who has her BS in Biology with a minor in Chemistry, who worked in an organic chemistry lab for 2 years and worked with many solvents used in extractions, compound purification, and analysis, and then went on to get an MS in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. She is extremely knowledgable when it comes to hexane and extraction methods, so I asked her for her thoughts on how concerned we should be about hexane-extracted DHA/ARA in the best organic baby formulas on this list. Here is the summary:
- Hexane is often used as extraction solvent for extracting fats. This is because it has a low boiling point when compared to most fats, which makes it easy to get rid of post-extraction – leaving the fat behind.
- To get rid of Hexane, chemists use a large apparatus called a “rotary vap” that gets rid of the solvents and you end up with a pure powder substance (usually a chemical compound). The next step is to check the purity of the compound using a machine called an NMR or MS, which tells you whether you have any of your solvent left.
- This woman told me that she never, ever found an issue with having hexane still present after drying her sample.
- Since formulas are a powder, they are heated to the point of water removal, and therefore the hexane should be all gone. It is unlikely that hexane is left in properly treated formula, but you are placing trust in the formula and manufacturing industry that all formula is being properly prepared.
- Note: All oils that don’t have a cold-pressed process are extracted using hexane – this includes corn oil, soy oil, vegetable oil, etc. (unless otherwise specified on the bottle). Hexane is also used during the development process for drugs – many drugs are purified in a hexane solvent and then it is dried off. So if you are going to question hexane, you need to be aware of the other areas where it is used in our regular food and drug supply!
- When it comes to being concerned about hexane vs. other questionable ingredients in organic formulas – maltodextrin, soy oil, etc., I’d be more concerned about maltodextrin vs. hexane extracted DHA. This is because maltodextrin’s glycemic index is much higher than table sugar and I personally believe a lot of issues today come from sugar and inflammation, and even when hexane is used it should be gone by the time the formula is packaged.
- Unfortunately, there is no formula out there that doesn’t have at least one of the “offending” ingredients in formula milk that I have listed above! For me personally, I would choose hexane-extracted DHA over maltodextrin or soy oil for example. This is because soy oil is also extracted using hexane, and maltodextrin has an extremely high glycemic index. In addition, formulas that contain soy oil or maltodextrin are 100% guaranteed to contain these ingredients, versus hexane which is likely not traceable in a formula that has used it as a method to extract DHA/ARA before the formula has been prepared!
Hi there! Amazing information, thank you. I’m predominantly breastfeeding my daughter but just started supplementing with HIPP Dutch 1. So far so good but was just told about Serenity Kids toddler formula. Do you still recommend HIPP Dutch over Serenity Kids and Bobbi? Serenity kids website says they meet nutritional requirements for infants and go into why it’s better formulated than European favorites. Wondering your thoughts! Thank you!
Hi Paige! I’m always hesitant to use a toddler formula for infants – which is why I’d pick HiPP Dutch over Serenity kids. Regarding ingredients between HiPP Dutch and Serenity kids, they’re comparable (both are very high quality). Regarding HiPP Dutch and Bobbie – honestly both are great. HiPP Dutch has a slight advantage in that it has both pre and probiotics, which means you wouldn’t have to supplement with anything if you used that formula. Bobbie doesn’t have pre/probiotics – so you would have to supplement. Hope that helps!
Hi Anjali
Between HIPP Uk , bellamys (Aus) and Kendamil what would be your top pick for stage 1? I have been trying to see some comparisons between the other two versus Bellamys but haven’t been able to find any. Any know-how on this would be super helpful!
Hi Vandana! Bellamys looks pretty comparable to Kendamil and HiPP UK actually – the main difference between these formulas is that Kendamil is vegetarian friendly (its DHA doesn’t come from fish oil), while Bellamys and HiPP UK uses DHA from fish. So I’d say if you want a vegetarian formula, choose Kendamil. If you don’t want a vegetarian formula, I’d pick the one that’s most affordable / easiest to get as you really can’t go wrong with any of these!
Hi Anjali,
My baby is drinking Enfamil Gentlease (colic, spit-ups, fussiness, gas etc.) and I want to switch her to something that is organic and similar to the above. I am looking at Hipp, Holle and Lebenswert but I don’t know which formula will suite her due to that fact she can’t take normal formula.
Any recommendations? I have been looking online and comparing which ones are better but I’m pretty much stuck and with the formula shortage, I need to order some as soon as possible.
Hi Vickie! Has your baby been diagnosed with a milk protein allergy, or do you just suspect she has a sensitivity? If it’s just a sensitivity, you could try HiPP HA as a next step as long as your pediatrician is supportive! If you have more questions, feel free to just book a time with me here and we can chat in more detail about all of the other options you could try if HiPP HA doesn’t work! Hope that helps!
Hello Anjali,
I see you’re recommending Hippe Dutch formula to all. But I see it contains palm oil in the ingredients as per your chart. May I know why you still recommend it?
Hi Sampath! Great question – honestly the reason is because there is no perfect formula that eliminates all ingredients that are less than ideal. HiPP Dutch is a super high quality formula in almost every way, and the only drawback is that it has palm oil. This makes it a much better choice than other formulas that may not contain palm oil but contain more than one other sub-optimal ingredient. I hope that helps explain how I’ve thought about the rankings!
Hi Anjali!
Thanks for all the great information, it really helps.
We started using HIPP Dutch 1 since day one and everything was great with it, until he turned 3 weeks old, that our baby started demanding more quantity than recommended and sooner than usual, so after trying everything without success, we switched to HIPP Germany 1, looking for a more satiating option within Hipp’s products even if it had starch, which we initially tried not to.
It hasn’t changed much, probably a tiny more satiating but our baby is still demanding more than the usual recommendations.
Do you have any experience or tip on that? Is there any option we should try other than what we’ve done to date? Would really appreciate your help on that.
Thanks a lot!
Rob
Hi Rob! Thanks for reaching out! Honestly, all of the European formulas are going to be about the same in terms of how long they keep your baby full for. There isn’t like a “hungry baby milk” option from Europe to try as far as I know. Also, as babies hit that 4 week mark, they do start to eat a lot more — and the quantity they eat tends to keep increasing until they hit about 5-6 months and start solids! How do you know your baby is demanding more milk than he should? Is your pediatrician concerned about how much he’s eating? I think I’d need more information in order to advise you properly! Feel free to book a time with me here and I’d be happy to answer all of your questions over the phone! 🙂
Hi Anjali,
Thanks for the valuable information. We were feeding our baby HiPP Dutch Stage 1. He is now six months and should we go ahead with Dutch Stage 2 or you recommend any other formula for six months and older babies.
Hi! If your baby has done well on HiPP Dutch, it makes sense to move him to Stage 2 now that he’s 6 months old — Stage 2 is designed specifically for babies aged 6 months and up. The formulation between Stage 1 and 2 is similar (Stage 2 has more iron and slightly different levels of other nutrients which older babies need). I wouldn’t switch to another brand entirely if HiPP Dutch is working well for you and him! Hope that helps!
Hi,
We have been using Bobbie but do to cost I am considering using Happy Baby Organic Stage 2, do you think this is a close second? Thank you!
Hi Courtney! Yes Happy Baby is a decent second place to Bobbie – the main difference is that Happy Baby contains palm oil, and Bobbie does not. Hope that helps!
There is a new supplier called Formula Vita.
They seem to have a large portfolio of products including Humana and Aptamil. Any experience? They say that they have the best baby formula from Europe.
Hi Krystel! I don’t know much about them unfortunately! I don’t know anyone at the company so haven’t gotten any info about them. But saying that they have the “best baby formula from Europe” is a bit of false marketing, since anyone who carries HiPP / Holle / Leb formulas are selling the same formula (e.g. HiPP Dutch is equally high quality no matter which distributor you are getting it from). The differentiators are price, reliability, shipping, sourcing, etc. Sorry I can’t be more helpful here!
This is extremely helpful! We’re in the process of infant adoption, and our baby is due in March! Just curious, what would you recommend to start out with, HiPP (Dutch) or Jovie Goat?
Hi Whitney! I’d probably just go with HiPP Dutch first, especially if your baby isn’t likely to have any major allergies (e.g. has no family history of food allergies). I’d switch to Jovie Goat or Loulouka Goat if your baby ends up having tummy troubles from the cow’s milk formula. Hope that helps, congrats on the adoption and on the soon-to-be-arrival of your little one! 🙂
Hi there. Curious how you would rank Burt’s Bees Organic Sensitive infant formula with Iron? Does this even come close to any of these formulas you have reviewed and ranked here?
Thank you!
Hi Danielle! I wouldn’t recommend it – the second ingredient is glucose syrup solids. It doesn’t come close to any of the formulas I’ve reviewed and ranked here! If you’re looking for a US based organic formula, I’d recommend Bobbie. If you’re looking for a hypoallergenic formula, I’d recommend HiPP HA. Hope that helps!
This article was exactly what I was looking for! THANK YOU for doing all this legwork, it is so appreciated!
My little one is 8 months and I managed to breastfeed her exclusively until now. My supply is just not enough anymore for her intake.
One brand I did not see in your list, that I am curious on your thoughts on is Babybim Ekobaby.
Looking forward to hearing from you.
Hi Bree! No problem at all – so glad this post was helpful! To your question, do you mean Biobim Lac ekobaby organic? If so, I actually can’t find a detailed ingredients list for this formula anywhere – which is why I haven’t included it on my list. It looks like it is organic, but beyond that I can’t tell you much! If you come across a detailed ingredients list feel free to send it to me and I can share my thoughts about it! Thanks!
Hi Anjali,
First I would like to thank you for providing us mamas all this information.
So with my first son I have used Holle and it was great.
This time around with my second son I’m very confused what to use after I’m done with my pumped breastmilk.
My son is born 6 weeks early, he’s getting breastmilk but soon I want to start giving him organic formula. I love Hipp dutch but was wondering if that is ok to give him since he’s born premature.
I give him multivitamin that contains iron so I’m not worried about the iron in the formula.
I would love your opinion to see which formula would be good to start with. My son is born 5 months ago but will turn 4 months actual.
I appreciate your help.
Hi Almara! If he is 4 months adjusted then HiPP Dutch should work just fine for him! I would try that since it’s more comprehensive and has slightly better ingredients than Holle. If your pediatrician is comfortable with you using HiPP Dutch, then I would go with that! Hope that helps!
Thank you so much for your reply.
My pediatrician is not fond of European formulas, but I am because of the cleaner ingredients. I followed your advice and started giving my baby Hipp Dutch and he’s doing great on it.
Thank you again for your help 🙂
So happy to hear that my post was helpful to you Almara! Glad your baby is doing well! 🙂
OMG I have used US brands because that’s what the pediatrician gave me after countless questions they still say yes yes this is perfect for your baby. I see the ingredients and am so upset I haven’t seen this sooner. My baby is 7months. I breastfeed and supplement with formula. Is it to late to switch formulas now that they are used to this one? Will new formula upset their stomach? The baby seems fine but I’m sure the formula hurts their stomach. Is there a formula in the US that is truly organic at all? seems like not so much. very very upset 🙁
Hi Elisa! Thanks so much for reaching out and I totally understand where you’re coming from! But it’s not too late to switch to organic formula, since your baby still has 5 months of formula feeding ahead of them! If you are looking for a 100% made in the US organic formula, I’d recommend Bobbie. If you’re interested in trying a European formula, I’d recommend HiPP Dutch. When you switch, just make sure you transition very slowly – over a period of 1-2 weeks, where you gradually increase the amount of new formula in each bottle and decrease the amount of the old one. That’ll make the transition much easier on your baby’s digestive system. Hope that helps!
Why is there no Bimbosan on this list? Is it that bad formula? As far as I’ve heard it’s the number 1 swiss formula
Hi Robert! I haven’t added Bimbosan yet because I haven’t gotten a detailed ingredients list to evaluate the formula in English yet, and I actually don’t even think there is a distributor who ships it to the US anymore (and historically it’s been pretty hard to get it). I’d go with one of the other formulas on my list instead!
Hi Anjali – I am having tough time in getting the HIPP dutch stage 2 delivered. I used dutchexpat and customs held it. Looking for recommendations on which sites to order from that will more likely gets delivered, have you heard any success stories? Thanks.
Hi Shanthi! My Organic Company has seemed to be pretty reliable with deliveries / doesn’t get held up in customs. I’d recommend ordering from them! Hope that helps!
Hello,
Thank you for this very in-depth detailed article regarding all things new parents need to know regarding formula, it’s been very helpful in helping us choose a formula to feed our son. We decided to purchase your top pick, Hipp Combiotik. After purchasing from and American company (Burps & Bottles), they were kind enough to send us a PFD file with preparation instructions and ingredients in English. Turns out, this formula has palm oil listed as an ingredient…? This was one ingredient we were trying to avoid according to your recommendations. Please offer your thoughts on this, as your write up calls out “vegetable oils”, but does not detail the fact that one of them is indeed palm oil.
Thank you.
Hi Gina! Thanks for reaching out! I’m glad you found this post helpful! To your question — you are right that I list palm oil as an ingredient to avoid if possible. The issue is, the majority of formulas, even European formulas include palm oil. There really is no perfect formula that fits all of the ideal criteria and so my ranking is based on which formula comes the closest. HiPP is my top pick because it includes everything a formula should have (DHA, ARA, Probiotics, Prebiotics, no added sugar or syrup, no starch, no synthetic nutrients) compared to the other formulas on my list. It’s only issue is the palm oil. For example, Loulouka – my #2 pick, has no palm oil, but also has no ARA (which is hard to supplement with) and no probiotics. Kendamil, which is my #3 pick, has no palm oil but also has no probiotics. So essentially you have to choose what is right for your baby. For my kids, the palm oil didn’t disturb their digestive system (that’s the main issue with palm oil), and so I chose HiPP because it was the most comprehensive. But if you’re concerned about palm oil and don’t mind supplementing, I’d try Loulouka or Kendamil. Out of all of the ingredients to avoid, my perspective is that palm oil is the least concerning. Hope that helps, let me know if you have any other questions!
I like Bobbie, but disappointed with the Soy oil they include. You recommend Bobbie as well, but say Soy should be avoided. Any insight on this?
Hi Megan! Great question! Bobbie does include soy oil, which I agree is not ideal, but the rest of their ingredients are really great and are on par with the European formulas on this list. The reality is that there just isn’t a US based formula that’s “perfect” from an ingredients standpoint, and Bobbie is the best US organic formula out there! The positive thing about soy oil is that it doesn’t have the same estrogenic effects as soy protein, so it’s less concerning than soy based formulas, etc. If you’re looking for a soy-free formula then I’d recommend one of the European formulas on my list! But if you don’t want to buy a European formula, Bobbie is going to be your best bet. Hope that helps!
What are your thoughts on the recent recall of many of the products you mention, for insufficient iron to meet babies’ needs?
Hi Lauren! Great question! Here are my thoughts:
From what I know, the term “recall” is inaccurate to describe what is going on with the FDA and European formulas right now. In my opinion, it seems like a loophole being used to shut Little Bundle down, because they weren’t in compliance with FDA regulations when it comes to distributing European formula in the US (they were doing US-to-US-shipment vs. Europe-direct-to-US-shipment). US-to-US-shipment for non-US products is not in compliance with the FDA. Here is what else I know about this “recall”:
– We have inquired directly with HiPP, Holle, Lebenswert and Kendamil and they have confirmed that there are no recalls on their products and they all continue to meet European nutritional requirements. Families in Europe are still using these formulas on a daily basis.
– US and EU standards are different for formula, but EU standards are actually more stringent than US standards.
– The iron levels in the EU formulas meet the EU requirements and standards for iron in infant formula.
– Kendamil (an EU formula) also meets the US standards for iron (as well as the EU standards). In fact, only 8 of the formulas listed in the recall don’t meet the US standards for iron, but over 20 formulas were recalled in total. (Again, this is why I think “recall” is not the term to be using for what’s going on)
– My opinion is that while not all of the EU formulas meet the US standards for iron, they do meet the EU standards, and families in Europe have been giving their children these formulas for literally decades with no issues and no reports about widespread effects of the “low” iron in their formulas.
– I gave both of my kids HiPP Dutch with no issues (their iron is normal).
– Other thoughts about iron: infants have iron stores from their mother that remain with them for 6 months after birth. After that, they’ll be getting iron from both solid foods and from formula or breastmilk. So formula won’t be their only source of iron. That is all to say that if it were my kids, I’d still use the European formula. But I’m not a doctor and you have to do what you feel most comfortable with for your kiddo (and what your pediatrician feels comfortable with as well!)
– I came across this article which outlines the FDA vs. EU requirements for infant formula in detail and shows how HiPP, Holle, Lebenswert stack up which might be helpful: https://medium.com/@santacrz1988/do-hipp-holle-and-lebenswert-meet-fda-nutritional-requirements-781a47f7cf35
That is all to say that if it were my kids, I’d still use the European formula. But I am not a doctor, and can’t give you medical advice. All I can say is that my opinion is this recall seems more of a method of shutting Little Bundle down than an issue with the formulas themselves. As with any decision, you should do what you think is best for your kid(s) and what your pediatrician feels comfortable with as well! If your pediatrician insists that you switch to a US based formula, I’d recommend Bobbie, as it’s the closest thing you’ll get to an EU formula. Hope that helps! Let me know if you have any other questions!
Hi. I have followed you for a few years. Burt’s Bees has new organic formulas. I would love your thoughts and reviews on them. Thanks.
Thanks for reaching out Katie! I hadn’t heard about Burt’s Bees Formulas but on first glance they look pretty good! They do contain palm oil, but they have DHA without hexane and they have prebiotics included, and it doesn’t look like they include any synthetic nutrients. I’d say it’s probably comparable to Bobbie, with Bobbie being slightly better because it doesn’t include palm oil (but Bobbie doesn’t have prebiotics). If you wanted to buy a US based formula, I’d say Bobbie and Burt’s Bees are probably the two best options. You just have to decide whether you’d rather have no palm oil and no prebiotics (Bobbie) or palm oil and prebiotics (Burts Bees). Hope that helps!
Hi Anjali,
I’ve been using the Hipp Dutch stage 1 formula for a couple months and noticed my baby gets a bit bloated and has a bit of spit up after. Do you think I should switch formulas if so is there a secondary one you would recommend? Thank you so much! Cali
Hi Cali! I would probably try Kendamil if HiPP Dutch isn’t sitting well with your daughter. When you do switch, make sure to do it very slowly, over a period of 1-2 weeks where you slowly increase the amount of the new formula and decrease the amount of the old one. Hope that helps!